Car Insurance Rates 2024

Are you curious about the current rates for car insurance in South Africa? Typically, the cost of Car Insurance in South Africa ranges from R150 to over R2000. There are mainly two types of car insurance available: Third-Party Insurance and Comprehensive Insurance.

Third-Party Car Insurance: This budget-friendly option covers damage to others’ vehicles and properties if you’re responsible for an accident. Monthly costs for Third-Party Car Insurance are generally between R150 and R500+.

Comprehensive Car Insurance: For broader protection, including damage to your own vehicle, theft, fire, and additional risks, Comprehensive Car Insurance is ideal. In South Africa, its cost varies from R800 to more than R2000 monthly, based on the car’s value and other criteria.

Keen to learn about car insurance pricing?

Understanding the Calculation of Car Insurance Costs

Navigating car insurance pricing involves grasping how insurers determine costs. These calculations largely depend on your car’s market value. We’ll delve into the specific formulas used for calculating both third-party and comprehensive insurance costs, based on a rate for every R100,000 of your car’s value.

Calculating Third-Party Insurance Premiums

Third-party insurance typically covers damage or injuries you might cause to others in an accident. 

  • Base Rate: R100 per (0.1% of R100,000)
  • Peak Rate: R200 up to (0.2% of R100,000)

Case Studies:

2018 Volkswagen Polo Vivo Hatch 1.4 Comfortline (Valued at R155,010)

Estimated third-party insurance cost ranges from R155 to R310

2003 Toyota Hilux 2400D LWB (Valued at R129,995)

Estimated third-party insurance cost ranges from R150 to R260

Determining Comprehensive Insurance Rates

Comprehensive insurance offers more extensive coverage, including potential damage to your own vehicle. The rates are generally higher.

  • Starting Rate: R300 per (0.3% of R100,000)
  • Maximum Rate: R900 up to (0.9% of R100,000)

Case  Studies:

2018 Toyota Hilux 2.8GD-6 Double Cab 4×4 Raider Auto (Valued at R573,009)

Comprehensive insurance cost estimates range from R1,720 to R5,160

2008 Volkswagen Polo 1.6 Comfortline (Valued at R119,995)

Comprehensive insurance cost estimates range from R360 to R1,080

Please be aware that the provided figures are indicative estimates. For a tailored and accurate insurance quote that aligns with your specific vehicle and circumstances, it is recommended to request a comprehensive quote. 

Factors Influencing Car Insurance Costs

Car insurance rates are determined by a multitude of factors. 

  • Type of Vehicle: Luxury and sports cars, as well as newer models, often incur higher insurance costs due to their higher repair or replacement expenses.
  • Driving Record: A history filled with accidents or traffic violations generally leads to increased premiums.
  • Location: Residing in urban areas, known for higher traffic and theft rates, usually results in elevated insurance rates.
  • Vehicle Storage: Securely storing your vehicle in a locked garage can lower insurance costs, thanks to the reduced risk of theft.
  • Vehicle Usage: Frequent use, especially for commuting, tends to increase insurance costs.
  • Security Features: Cars equipped with safety and anti-theft features like alarms, immobilisers, and tracking devices may qualify for reduced rates.
  • Insurance History: Your past dealings with insurers, including claims history and any coverage gaps, can impact your current rates.
  • Age and Gender of Driver: Younger drivers, particularly males under 25, often face higher insurance rates.
  • Chosen Deductible: Higher deductibles can lower your premiums but mean greater out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim.

Coverage Type and Limits: Opting for more comprehensive coverage and higher limits typically increases the insurance cost.

Determining Your Car Insurance Needs

Let’s evaluate Third-Party, Fire and Theft insurance against Comprehensive insurance.

Third-party, Fire and Theft Insurance


  • Cost-Effectiveness: Generally cheaper than comprehensive insurance.
  • Basic Coverage: Includes damage to others’ property, and covers your vehicle for fire and theft.
  • Peace of Mind: Offers a balance between minimal and extensive coverage.


  • Limited Protection: Does not cover damages to your car in at-fault accidents.
  • Less Suitable for High-Value Cars: Might not offer adequate coverage for more expensive vehicles.

Ideal For: This is a great choice if you seek more than basic third-party coverage but don’t require full protection. It’s especially apt for older or less valuable cars, where comprehensive insurance costs might be disproportionate.

Comprehensive Car Insurance


  • Extensive Coverage: Protects against a wide range of incidents, including accidents, theft, fire, vandalism, and weather-related damages.
  • Greater Security: Perfect for higher-value cars.
  • Additional Benefits: Often includes extras like roadside assistance.


  • Higher Costs: More expensive than third-party, fire and theft insurance.
  • Potentially Unnecessary for Older Cars: For older, low-value vehicles, the costs might surpass the benefits.

Ideal For: Comprehensive insurance is recommended if you own a newer or more valuable car, or if you desire maximum protection and peace of mind. It’s also a wise choice if you depend on your vehicle for daily activities, particularly in areas with high traffic or crime rates.

Quick Tips for Saving on Car Insurance

  • Reassess Car Hire Coverage: Consider removing this if unnecessary. Use alternative transportation methods to reduce premiums.
  • Choose Third-Party Insurance: If comprehensive insurance is beyond your budget, this more affordable option can be a suitable alternative.
  • Install Safety Features: Adding alarms or tracking devices can lead to lower premiums.
  • Utilise Low-Mileage Discounts: Available for vehicles driven less than 15,000km/year.
  • Bundle Insurance Policies: Combine your vehicle and home insurance to receive discounts.
  • Reconsider All-Risk Coverage: Exclude items that are always at home from all-risk coverage, as home insurance already covers them.
  • Opt for Higher Voluntary Excess: Increasing your excess can lead to reduced monthly premiums.

How Compare Car Insurance Can Save You Money

Using Compare Car Insurance can lead to significant savings on your car insurance. Here’s how this service can help you cut costs:

  • Comprehensive Comparison: Compare Car Insurance provides a platform to compare quotes from various insurers, ensuring you find the best deal that matches your needs and budget.
  • Tailored Options: By understanding your specific requirements, Compare Car Insurance can suggest policies that offer the best value for money, avoiding unnecessary coverages that inflate costs.
  • Expert Advice and Insights: With their knowledge of the industry, Compare Car Insurance’s experts can guide you to make informed decisions, helping you choose coverages that are cost-effective without compromising on essential protection.
  • Access to Exclusive Deals: Often, Compare Car Insurance has access to deals and discounts not available directly to consumers, which can lead to additional savings

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Insurance

What’s the difference between Third-Party and Comprehensive Insurance?

Third-party insurance covers damages to others’ property in accidents you’re responsible for. Comprehensive Insurance includes this and also covers your vehicle for various risks like accidents, theft, and natural disasters.

Can I change my insurance policy once it’s active?

Yes, most insurance companies permit policy modifications. However, check your policy’s terms or consult your insurer for specifics.

Does car insurance cover theft?

Comprehensive insurance typically includes theft coverage, but Third-Party Insurance does not. For theft protection, Comprehensive Insurance is the better choice.

How can I lower my car insurance premiums?

Lower premiums can be achieved by opting for a higher deductible, maintaining a clean driving record, installing car security features, and in some cases, by improving your credit score.

Are older cars cheaper to insure?

Generally, yes, due to their lower value. However, very old or classic cars might require specialized 

What factors affect my car insurance rate?

Influencing factors include your car’s make and model, age, driving history, location, frequency of use, security features, insurance history, and your chosen coverage and deductibles.

Is it mandatory to have car insurance in South Africa?

It’s not legally required in South Africa, but having at least Third-Party Insurance is highly recommended for financial protection.

What is a deductible in car insurance?

A deductible is what you pay out-of-pocket in a claim before your insurance coverage kicks in. A higher deductible can mean lower premiums.

Does car insurance cover damage from natural disasters?

Such coverage is usually included in Comprehensive insurance, but not in Third-Party Insurance.

Can I insure a car that’s not in my name?

It’s possible, but insurance policies vary. Some insurers require the policyholder to be the registered owner. Always verify the specifics with your insurer.

Get A Quote Now

Average savings of over R3500 per year for drivers who get multiple quotes

Get Multiple Car Insurance Quotes Now


Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Average savings of over R3500 per year for drivers who get multiple quotes

Get Multiple Car Insurance Quotes Now